This article was just brought to my attention. I know jewelers are often viewed through the same lens as the average used car salesman. Calling us all weasels is, well, uncalled for.
I would like to take this opportunity to illustrate how I value jewelry and point out a few factors that may not be immediately apparent when calculating the payout.
You are selling your jewelry as scrap. Remember when you collected cans to sell to the local scrap guy by weight? Same concept. Your jewelry is probably going to be sold off, by weight, to someone who buys scrap gold and silver or sent to a precious metals refinery like Hoover & Strong.
You will not get the full value of the metals.
- Precious metals markets fluctuate, sometimes wildly. Gold my be $1200 per troy ounce today and only $1000 tomorrow. Conversely, it may be $1000 today and $1200 tomorrow. One never knows. A certain amount of risk is involved and the jeweler is going to try and protect him or herself from that.
- The jeweler does not receive full value for the metals. The refinery charges a fee for their services and pays out a percentage of the metal value based on the market price. A scrap buyer also only pays a percentage of the market value.
- Store overhead is also a factor. The person valuing your jewelry probably gets paid by the hour. The light bill and rent must also be paid.
- The equipment for this is expensive. A good quality gold tester, diamond tester and scale will cost over $1000.
Diamonds under a certain size may not have value.
- If the jewelry goes to a scrap buyer, he probably does not pay extra for small diamonds. Anything smaller than .05ct is not worth the labor cost to remove.
- Some refineries will return the diamonds, for a fee, but that is not always the case.
- If you wish to keep your diamonds, a jeweler can usually remove them for a fee.
Colored stones are usually dead weight.
- With the prevalence of treated, synthetic and imitation stones in the market, a trained gemologist is required to positively identify them. Fees to identify stones, in most cases, will outstrip the value of the gemstones in question.
- Colored gems often show wear which makes them unsuitable for resale.
- If you wish to keep your colored gems, a jeweler can usually remove them for a fee.
The Math
Most gold jewelry sold in the US is marked in karats. To explain where some of the numbers come from: 24kt is the element Au (gold) and stamped 999. It is never assumed to be absolutely pure, hence the 999 mark. For durability and cost reasons it is usually combined with other metals which reduces the amount of gold on the alloy. Think of the karat system as fractions: 18k is eighteen twenty-fourths gold (18/24), 14k is 14/24, and so on. This is dealt with on the international level as three digit numbers indicating the percentage content of gold. For example, 14k is also indicated by the number 585, or 58.5%. The numbers your jeweler should use to calculate for gold content are as follows:
- 24k – 999
- 18k – 750
- 14k – 585
- 10k – 417
If you look in the newspaper at the comodities section you will find gold (24k) priced per troy ounce. This is also called the Spot price. Follow this link to Wikipedia for more about troy ounces. Since your jeweler is going to weigh your jewelry in grams, you should know that one troy ounce is 31.1 grams.
You now have enough information to make the calculations yourself, if you wish. We will assume that gold is $1000 per ounce at the time of this transaction and this jeweler pays out 75% of spot. Grab a calculator and follow along.
Determine the spot price of gold per gram: 1000 ÷ 31.1 = $32.15 Now you can calculate the value of the karated golds:
- 18k per gram: $32.15 x .750 = $24.11
- 14k per gram: $32.15 x .585 = $18.80
- 10k per gram: $32.15 x .417 = $13.40
You have 15 grams of 10k, 26 grams of 14k, and 8 grams of 18k to sell
- 18k: 8 grams x $24.11 = $192.88
- 14k: 26 grams x $18.80 = $488.80
- 10k: 15 grams x $13.40 = $201.00
- Total gold spot value: $882.68
Payout: $882.68 x .75 = $662.01
What reduces the profit margin for the jeweler:
- Time to calculate and explain everything to your satisfaction cost in payroll
- Recouping equipment costs, say $2 per transaction if spread over 500 transactions
- Shipping and insurance to the rifinery and their fees
- The price of gold may go down
Other Factors
Yes, it is possible that some of your pieces may be refurbished and put out for sale if your jeweler sells estate jewelry. You may be paid slightly more for these pieces.
If a gemologist is on staff, you may be paid for your colored gems if they are of acceptable quality and value for resale.
If, for any reason, the transaction feels wrong to you you can always walk away. If you need something explained or clarified make sure they do it to your satisfaction. Have everything written down so you can see it, just like I showed you above. I hope this helps take some of the mystery of selling your jewelry for cash.
If I can clarify anything further, leave a comment and I will do my best to answer your questions.